For the last 15 years or so, local Time Machine backup storage has been required to be included in the volumes that are indexed by Spotlight. We also know too well that they have been indexed, as it has been common for their indexing to take longer than the backup they have just made. Some time around the release of Sonoma, those indexing sessions became less noticeable, but unless you tried to search your backups, you probably didn’t notice any change. For, as far as I can tell, Spotlight doesn’t currently appear able to search Time Machine backups reliably, at least not in Sequoia or Tahoe, although this may not be universal.

For most purposes, the ability to search backups is essential. If you have a series of more than 100 backups over the last couple of years, finding a lost file by inspecting each backup individually is a frustrating waste of time, and requires you to know where to look in each. Even if full content and metadata searching aren’t feasible, the ability to search on file attributes such as name, extension and datestamps is surely fundamental.

As we’ve come to expect, Apple’s documentation isn’t in the least bit helpful. What is surprising is that the instructions given are almost identical for every version of macOS from Mojave to Tahoe.

That page opens with a bold promise: “If you use Time Machine to back up your Mac, you can use Spotlight to initiate a search of Time Machine to recover lost or deleted items.”

That’s just what I’m looking for, so how do I do that? “On your Mac, open a Finder window, then type a search word or phrase in the search field in the upper-right corner. Refine the results by specifying search criteria using the search bar.”

Everything’s good so far, but as the document I’m looking isn’t there, how do I search for it in my backups? “Click the Time Machine icon in the menu bar, then choose ‘Browse Time Machine backups’.”

That opens the Time Machine app, blows away my search criteria, and lists the volumes including Macintosh HD and my backup storage, as of now. So how do I search for the file that I accidentally deleted a couple of hours ago?

“Use the arrows and timeline to browse the Time Machine backups.” But that’s looking for the missing file, not searching those backups for it.

If I now step back through my backups to reach one that I know contains that file, I can restore it. But if I type anything into the search field, nothing is found. If I change the scope of the search to that backup, the window title changes but its contents remain blank, and there isn’t even a busy spinner to indicate a search is in progress.

With a little fiddling, I managed to get some results for other searches. Here’s an example where I was looking for files whose name contains logui with the extension swift.

Here I ended up with 102 hits, all of them old Fortran source files, none of which meets either of those criteria.

This time the two items found had appropriate names, but a completely different extension.

Undeterred, I left my Mac for over 24 hours, and tried again, only to discover the hourly backup containing my missing file had already been deleted. However, searching for files whose name contains logui with the extension swift proved just as futile. As I can’t disable Spotlight indexing on that volume without macOS telling me that it’s required to be indexed by Spotlight, neither can I force that volume to be reindexed.

There are third-party alternatives, including BackupLoupe and Find Any File (FAF). The former tellingly needs to create and maintain its own indexes, and FAF appears to work fairly reliably but takes an age to search each backup in turn.

In case this was a problem with one set of backups, I have now created a new backup set that suffers identical problems, and have reproduced this in both Sequoia and Tahoe, running on vastly different hardware. My conclusion is that using Spotlight to search Time Machine backups no longer works, and the instructions given by Apple are also broken. If you’ve managed to get reliable search working across your Time Machine backups without resorting to a third-party product, I’d be very grateful if you could explain how you did it.