In 1913, Emily Carr’s exhibition of two hundred of her paintings of totems and villages of the First Nations in the Pacific North-West had flopped. Despite trying to enlist the support of the minister of education in British Columbia, her art had been rejected, even being refused by the new provincial museum.
Carr returned to Victoria, and opened a boarding house on Simcoe Street, painting infrequently. But she did not stop painting altogether, and by the late 1920s was travelling to indigenous villages again to study and paint First Nations culture.
Carr continued to paint in Fauvist style over this time, as seen in her Logging Camp (c 1920).
This painting of an Arbutus Tree (1922) makes a fascinating contrast with her previous watercolour of the same species from about 1909. This tree is painted much more loosely and in vibrant high chroma.
In 1924, Emily Carr met with Seattle artists, most importantly Mark Tobey, who helped her rebuild confidence in her art.
Her Self-portrait from 1924-25 shows her still suffering from her rejection, though. Most unusually for a self-portrait, she faces away from the viewer, and is working on a painting which is unrecognisably vague and formless.
A visit by Eric Brown, director of the National Gallery of Canada, made 1927 the turning point in Carr’s art. She was invited to join the Group of Seven in a major exhibition in Ottawa, and twenty-six of her oil paintings, together with pottery and hooked rugs made when running the boarding house, were shown there. She became particularly close to Lawren Harris (1885-1970), who became her mentor.
In the summer of 1928, Carr made her first major trip north since 1913, to the Nass and Skeena Rivers and Haida Gwaii. Among the important paintings which resulted is this superb watercolour of a totem presumably at Ankeda (1928).
Kitwancool (1928) shows a forest of poles at a village now known as Gitanyow, populated by the Gitxsan. This is near the Kitwanga River, which is a tributary of the Skeena, in north-west British Columbia. This village is now a National Historic Site.
Carr’s watercolour of a Queen Charlotte Islands Totem (1928) shows another site in what is now known as Haida Gwaii, which she had visited extensively in the years prior to 1913.
The Raven (1928-19) is a precursor of one of Carr’s best-known paintings, Big Raven (1931), and shares with it a motif based on a huge carved raven silhouetted against the sky, and the sculptural forms of trees. These were derived from an early watercolour painted at Cumshewa in 1912, which shows this massive totem. It heralds a new emphasis in Carr’s painting on the modelling of forms, which was influenced by Lawren Harris in particular.
Blunden Harbour (c 1930) shows Carr’s evolving style particularly well. This village, inhabited by ‘Nak’waxda’xw (Nakoaktok) of the Kwakwaka’wakw peoples, was on the coast of the British Columbian mainland opposite Haida Gwaii, seen to the right, at the mouth of the Queen Charlotte Strait.
It was an isolated community, and in 1964, its population was forced to relocate to Port Hardy, about sixteen miles away. Before the last of its inhabitants had even left in their boats, officials set fire to the village and burnt it to the ground, to ensure that no one would try to return.
There is uncertainty as to the source of Carr’s motif; it has been claimed that she painted this from a photograph of the village taken in 1901 by the ethnographer Charles F Newcombe. However, the great majority of Carr’s paintings of the north-west appear to have been painted from life, rather than old photographs taken by others.
Path among Pines (c 1930) is another sign of the changes taking place in Carr’s art at this time. Its trees are solid forms, with swirling hues over their surfaces. The path swoops up into the distance in a carved curve. Totems would remain important in Carr’s art, but she was now taking to the forest too.
By 1930, Carr’s career was transformed. She was a national if not international success, and travelled to New York, where she met Georgia O’Keeffe among others. She exhibited with the Group of Seven that year too. It is often stated that Emily Carr was a ‘late developer’: I hope that you agree that it was not her late development, but the shocking delay in the recognition of her art.
Lisa Baldissera (2015) Emily Carr, Life & Work, Art Canada Institute. ISBN 978 1 4871 0044 5. Available in PDF from Art Canada Institute.
Thom, Ian M (2013) Emily Carr Collected, Douglas & McIntyre. ISBN 978 1 77100 080 2.